Why Students Confuse b and d (And What Actually Helps)

|

Most tutors and teachers using the Orton-Gillingham approach have at least one student (or ten!) who confuses b and d. It’s common!

And if a student has dyslexia, this confusion can stick around longer and feel more frustrating for both the student and the teacher.

The letters b and d are mirror images of each other. For a developing reader, especially one still building visual memory, this makes them easy to mix up.

It’s not just a student who is not “getting it,” it’s part of how the brain is learning to process these letters.

In an Orton-Gillingham scope and sequence:

  • b is taught first
  • d comes later

Each letter is taught individually, with:

  • A keyword
  • The sound
  • Proper letter formation (with tracing and saying the letter)

B and D are NOT taught together. The confusion usually shows up later, once students begin reading and writing more independently. That’s when you step in with support.

You don’t need special activities to teach b and d. You use them only if a student is confusing them. That’s an important distinction.

This isn’t something you plan for ahead of time in your scope and sequence. It’s something that comes up as students begin applying what they’ve learned.

Watch on YouTube for video help.

Draw the word bed like this:

b = headboard
d = footboard

This gives students a quick visual they can recall when reading or writing.

Have students:

  • Trace b and d in sand, shaving cream, or on textured surfaces
  • Say the letter sound while tracing

This builds muscle memory, not just visual recognition.

This one is too good not to share. A fellow tutor brought:

  • broccoli (for b)
  • donut (for d)

Then use the phrase: “Eat your broccoli before your dessert.” Kids love this and remember it.

Students improve their writing skills by having plenty of opportunities for practice.

Have students:

  • Write words (not just letters)
  • Have the student draw pictures of b/d (bear/dog) and label (make it multi-sensory!)
  • Use dictation

As writing becomes more automatic, confusion decreases.

You may also see confusion with p and q. Same idea — mirror images, same type of support.

Confusing b and d is completely normal. With:

  • Clear instruction
  • Multisensory practice
  • Memory cues

Students can move past it, and they do!

If you’re trying to figure out:

  • When to step in
  • What to focus on next
  • How this fits into lessons

You can get started here for $79: The Orton Gillingham Fast Track. It breaks down the foundations of structured literacy and shows how they come together in real lessons.

You can also fast-track early learning with the Read & Spell Foundations System Consonants & Short Vowels. It’s here to guide you through teaching those early reading and spelling skills.

Similar Posts

2 Comments

  1. Hi! Thank you for sharing these ideas to help reduce or eliminate b/d confusion in reading and spelling. I enjoyed the video and that you highlighted the need for teaching “b” and “d” separately and far apart, but was a little disappointed you didn’t show the correct formation of the “d” when you were discussing the strategies. You did show the correct formation of the “b”; though not in a deliberate way. I believe the correct formation of both “b” and “d” is so important to help combat b/d confusion. I can see in your handwriting models that you utilize the correct strokes during instruction, and hope you’ll demonstrate the correct formation of a “b” and “d” in another video. Thanks again! Aloha, Cindy

    1. Hi Cindy, I can see how that felt like it was missing. I was really concentrating on the strategies themselves and probably assumed the formation piece was already in place, but you’re right, it’s an important part of the whole picture. Correct formation really does make a difference! I’ll definitely plan to include that more clearly in a future video.

      Thank you so much for your thoughtful input!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *